Women are underrepresented as lead authors on published randomised controlled trials in nephrology and there has been no sign of progress over the past decade, a study has found.
The systematic review, published in Kidney International Reports [link here], identified 395 nephrology RCTs that met the criteria including being published in high-impact journals from general medicine, nephrology, and kidney transplantation between 2011 and 2021.
It found the proportion of women in lead authorship positions was 22.5% overall. Rates of female corresponding, first and last authorship positions on the RCTs were 22%, 28%, and 19% respectively, without change over the study period.
Female lead authorship was low among general medicine journals with the highest impact factors such as JAMA (15.0%), NEJM (15.0%) and The Lancet (17.6%).
Among nephrology journals, the American Journal of Kidney Diseases had the highest proportion of women in lead authorship positions (38%) followed by the Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology (26.1%).
The median percentage of women participants in the trials was 40.2% across the whole study period.
The study also noted that most trials did not report sex-specific eligibility criteria (71.1%) or perform gender-specific subgroup analysis (87.3%).
However RCTs led by women nephrologists were more likely to have sex-specific eligibility criteria than not.
“Overall, women were less likely to be enrolled in nephrology RCTs as participants but more likely to be enrolled when women were lead authors,” the study authors said.
“Participation is crucial given the sex disparities in kidney disease pathogenesis and progression and can lead to better health outcomes for women with kidney disease.”
The authors said their findings demonstrate ongoing underrepresentation of women in nephrology trial leadership despite improved representation in leadership and presidency positions in organisations including the International Society of Nephrology.
“However, gaps remain with women underrepresented in national conferences and academic grand rounds, receiving fewer achievement awards, and are less likely to be listed as first author,” they said
“These disparities can contribute to women being left out of leadership roles and can impact their growth and promotion.”
Australian perspective
ANZSN president Associate Professor Rathika Krishnasamy, from the Sunshine Coast University Hospital and University of Queensland, told the limbic that the findings were not surprising given the wider gender equity issues in nephrology.
She said ANZSN had already identified the issues locally – see 2022 workforce survey findings here – and had been working towards gender equity in the workplace, academic science and research.